Senate Democrats

Bush Budget Inadequately Addresses Issues Important to the Asian American and Pacific Islander Community

President Bush’s budget for Fiscal Year 2008 would once again severely cut programs that directly affect the quality of life for many Asian American and Pacific Islanders (AAPIs).  The following report assesses the President’s spending plan compared to the levels provided in H.J.Res.20, the Funding Resolution for Fiscal Year 2007, recently passed in the House of Representatives and the Senate.  The President’s cuts in funding for education, health care, labor, housing, and economic assistance programs will have a negative impact on AAPI families across the nation.  Democrats believe these cuts reflect misplaced priorities that are wrong not just for the AAPI community, but for all Americans. Democrats are committed to taking the country in a new direction./

Health Care and Nutrition

Health care costs, including health insurance premiums, have skyrocketed since President Bush took office.  In 2005, 46.6 million people in the United States, or 15.9 percent, were without health insurance coverage.  The AAPI community, however, experienced higher rates of uninsurance at 17.7 percent for Asian Americans and 21.8 percent for Pacific Islanders.  The situation was worst for Korean and Southeast Asian Americans, who were most likely to be uninsured.  Challenges to health care access for the AAPI community include language and immigration barriers, as well as unfamiliarity with public health programs, which is why AAPIs are underrepresented beneficiaries of government-sponsored programs.  Thus, it is vital that key programs, such as SCHIP, Medicaid, and Medicare, have the resources needed to reach out to the AAPI community.  Yet, even in the face of this crisis, President Bush proposed cuts to vital health care programs that benefit — and should benefit more — low-income AAPI families. 

The Bush budget jeopardizes AAPI children by undermining the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP).  Although 11.2 percent of children, including 12.2 percent of Asian American children, are without health insurance, the budget proposes adding only one-third of the funding necessary to maintain current coverage levels in SCHIP, which will put millions of low-income children and others at risk of losing their health insurance.  Moreover, the President’s plan would leave millions of low-income children who are eligible for the program without coverage.

The President proposes nearly $300 billion in cuts over ten years to Medicare and Medicaid.  These cuts will further exacerbate the country’s uninsurance crisis because hundreds of thousands of AAPI seniors and families depend upon these programs for their health care.

·        Medicare. Approximately 43 million senior citizens and people with disabilities depend on Medicare.  The President proposes $76 billion in legislative and regulatory cuts over five years, and $252 billion in legislative cuts over 10 years. 

·        The budget proposes to increase the number of Medicare beneficiaries subject to higher premiums in Parts B and D.  By preventing the income threshold for the higher premiums from increasing to reflect inflation, more middle class beneficiaries in the AAPI community will be affected by the higher premium, and one of the greatest strengths of the Medicare program – its universality – will erode. 

·        Moreover, the President’s budget favors privately managed plans over traditional Medicare providers.  The budget proposes to reduce payment updates to hospitals and other health care providers participating in the traditional fee-for-service Medicare program, but maintains overpayments to HMOs and other managed care plans even though MedPAC, an independent advisory panel, has recommended their elimination.

·        Medicaid.  More than 50 million low-income people – approximately one out of six Americans – depend on Medicaid for their health care.  15.9 percent of Asian children are covered by Medicaid.  Just last year, the Republican-controlled Congress enacted $6.9 billion in Medicaid cuts over five years.  Now the President is proposing additional cuts.  The budget, through legislative proposals and regulatory changes, proposes $25 billion in Medicaid cuts over five years.

The Bush budget for food and nutrition programs would limit availability and access to federal nutrition programs for low-income AAPIs.  Approximately 11.5 percent of AAPIs live below the poverty line.  Nevertheless, the budget proposes eliminating categorical eligibility for food stamp recipients who receive TANF-funded work support services.  Approximately 329,000 individuals would be affected by 2009 and nearly $1.4 billion would be cut from federal nutrition programs.  The budget also proposes the elimination of the Commodity Supplemental Food Program for low-income children and senior citizens, which would eliminate modest monthly food packages for almost half a million individuals.  In addition, the budget proposes funding cuts for the Women Infants and Children (WIC) program’s nutrition and education services for low-income mothers and children.

The budget once again proposes cuts to health promotion programs.  While investing in preventive health programs is both common sense and good medicine, the President proposes to cut overall funding for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and again proposes eliminating the Preventive Health Bock Grants.  The President’s budget would also eliminate the Universal Newborn Screening program, even though the national infant mortality rate is near 6.5 percent.

The Bush Administration’s budget proposal also cuts funding to veteran health care programs.  America has a special obligation to support and honor the 24.5 million veterans – nearly 200,000 of whom are AAPIs — who have risked their lives to defend our nation and its interests.  The President’s budget, however, inadequately provides for their health care needs.  The budget nearly doubles the prescription drug co-payment for approximately two million middle income veterans who suffer from non-service related disabilities, and it continues a ban on new middle-income veterans enrolling for care, a policy that has caused as many as one million veterans to be turned away from VA hospitals and clinics.  Further, the budget provides only minimal funds for enhancements in specialized VA health care programs, including mental health/substance abuse treatment, rehabilitative care for critically wounded service members, and readjustment counseling.  The proposal also underestimates the needs of the new generation of veterans arriving home from Afghanistan and Iraq.  While the President’s request of $752 million for health care services for returning Iraq and Afghanistan war veterans represents an increase over current spending levels, it is projected that this allocation will fall short of real demand by 50,000 patients. 


The President’s budget proposal fails to adequately fund critical programs that provide educational opportunities for AAPI students.  Modest increases in discretionary funding for some programs would be offset by cuts in funding for, or the elimination of, other vital education programs.  The President’s budget would cut Department of Education discretionary funding by $2.3 billion, or 3.9 percent. Instead of adequately investing in education, the President is once again asking students, parents, and teachers to do more with less.

The Bush budget under-funds No Child Left Behind (NCLB) and Title I. Though the President trumpets NCLB as a way to close the academic achievement gaps impacting minority students, his budget once again fails to provide adequate resources to fund the program, even as states and local school districts struggle to meet the program’s requirements.  While the budget increases NCLB funding by $738 million above baseline, for a total of $24.6 billion, which reflects a $968 million increase for state grants under Title I, these new funds are targeted toward new requirements for high schools.  The Bush budget does little to help schools meet the goals that have already been established.  Even worse, where the budget gives with one hand, it takes away with the other by proposing $397 million in budget cuts for K-12 education programs.

The President’s budget also inadequately funds Title III of NCLB, the Language Assistance State Grants.   English Language Learners (ELLs) currently make up over 10 percent of all students attending public schools.  Over the past fifteen years, the ELL student enrollment has nearly doubled, and it is predicted that one-quarter of the total U.S. public school population will be ELL by the year 2025.  The President’s budget, however, fails to appropriately fund English language development programs so that ELL students can achieve at the same academic levels as other children. 

The Bush budget fails to make college more affordable for AAPI students. In spite of the dramatically rising costs of college, the President’s budget does not address growing concerns about the affordability of a college education.  The President’s budget only contains enough discretionary funds to maintain the current maximum Pell Grant of $4,050.  While the President proposes an increase in the maximum Pell Grants from $4,050 to $4,600 in Fiscal Year 2008 and to $5,400 by Fiscal Year 2012, he aims to pay for part of the increases with cuts and program eliminations that would hurt other students.  The President proposes to eliminate the Perkins Loan, Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grants, and Leveraging Education Assistance Partnerships programs, which would negatively impact the 37 percent of Asian Americans and 36.2 percent of Pacific Islanders who access student loans. 

The President rejects bipartisan support for career and technical education.  Last year, Congress passed and the President signed a bill to reauthorize and strengthen career and technical education.  Despite overwhelming bipartisan support for these programs, the President’s Fiscal Year 2008 budget proposes a $696 million reduction in funding.  As a result, most states would see their funding reduced by almost half, and five million secondary students and three million post-secondary students participating in career and technical education programs, as well as more than two million students enrolled in Tech Prep programs, could see their courses reduced or eliminated.  

The budget shortchanges after-school programs for AAPI students.  21st Century Learning Centers provide enrichment and a safe and supervised environment for students after the school day ends.  Nevertheless, the President proposes flat-funding this program at $981 million, which is $19 million less than what is needed to provide the same level of services in 2008 as will be provided in 2007.

The Bush budget provides inadequate funding for Head Start.  The Head Start program prepares many low-income AAPI children to enter kindergarten ready to learn by providing child development, education, health, nutrition and other services.  The Bush budget would cut Head Start by $207 million, for a total of $6.79 billion.  The program currently serves only about one-half of the children eligible for the pre-school program, and fewer than five percent of eligible Early Head Start children.  By failing to provide a cost-of-living adjustment, the President’s budget will result in cuts in hours, transportation, and educational instruction that will reduce the number of children receiving services and threaten the quality of the program.

The President would eliminate Even Start.  Even Start is a family-focused program, which offers early childhood education, adult education, parenting education, and interactive literacy activities for parents and children.  Though AAPI families are underrepresented participants in the program (only 2 percent) due to language barriers and lack of awareness, the program is a vital resource in educating both children and parents.  Thus, instead of eliminating the program, steps should be made to increase AAPI participation in it.

The budget would cut programs that promote safe and drug-free schools. Safe and drug-free school programs have provided millions of children with a safe environment that allows them to learn.  Despite their success, the President proposes cuts of $253 million, or 72 percent, for safe and drug-free schools state grants.  The budget would leave only $100 million for these vital programs.

The Bush budget would terminate other key education programs.  The President proposes to eliminate 44 discretionary education programs, including Leveraging Education Assistance Partnership Grants (LEAP), education technology state grants, school counseling, mentoring, parent information and resource centers, physical education, school leadership, Tech Prep State grants, and the School Dropout Prevention Program. 

Housing and Community Development

The Bush budget would reduce funding for housing programs that assist AAPIs in need.  At a time when more and more Americans are being squeezed by high rent, high home heating costs, and high oil prices, the Bush budget proposes to cut funding for programs to assist lower income Americans with their housing needs.  For example, the President’s budget would significantly cut funding for the: Housing for the Elderly program, which supports the creation of housing facilities for lower income elderly Americans aged 62 years and above; the Housing for Persons with Disabilities program, which provides construction grants, operating subsidies, and housing vouchers for lower income Americans with disabilities; and the Project-based Rental Assistance program, including under-funding the Section 8 Tenant-based assistance program.

The budget would cut funding for Community Development Block Grants.  The Bush budget proposes to cut funding for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program by $736 million below the H.J.Res.20 level.  The CDBG program provides eligible metropolitan areas with annual direct grants that can be used to revitalize neighborhoods, expand affordable housing and economic opportunities, and improve community facilities and services.

Employment and Training Programs


The Bush budget would cut funding for employment and job training programs that benefit hardworking AAPIs.  These cuts could not come at a worse time for workers who are struggling to support their families in the face of layoffs, competitiveness, wage stagnation, and the increasing cost of living.  Nevertheless, the President is asking Congress to cut these programs by $1 billion, or 19 percent, which includes funding decreases for the adult employment and training activities grant program, dislocated worker employment and training activities grant program, youth activities program, Job Corps and the Community Service Employment Program for Older Americans.  In various ways, these programs help states and localities provide extensive job training and placement for workers and students and offer necessary services to employers. 

The Bush budget would cut $27 million in funding from the fiscal year 2007 levels for the Employment Service State grants program, which helps unemployed workers find jobs.  Given that the national unemployment rate rose to 4.6 percent in January, one in every five of these workers remains unemployed for more than six months, and there are over 220,000 AAPIs looking for work, these grants are vitally important. 

The budget would also drastically cut funding for programs that help AAPIs with disabilities.  The budget eliminates funding for the Work Incentive Grant program, which makes grants to help operate one-stop career centers to assist job seekers with disabilities.  One-stop centers provide enhanced career development and labor market information services to many AAPI workers and employers.  Further, the budget reduces funding by $10.3 million, or 35.6 percent, below baseline for the Office of Disability Employment Policy, which works to eliminate employment barriers to people with disabilities. 

 Economic Development and Assistance

 The Bush budget eliminates key funding for AAPI small businesses. The Bush budget once again proposes to eliminate funding for the microloan and microloan technical assistance programs, which were funded at $22 million and $13 million, respectively, for 2007.  These loans are essential to many AAPI businesspersons, who own well over 1.1 million firms in the United States.  Many of these businesses are small businesses that serve their local community and provide good-paying, stable jobs.  Supporting these businesses is not only vital to the success of the AAPI community, it is vital to the success of our nation. 

The President would cut clean water programs.   Funding to improve water quality would be cut by $400 million, from $1.9 billion in the in H.J.Res.20 to $1.5 billion in Fiscal Year 2008.  The Clean Water Act state revolving fund, which provides important funding to states for wastewater treatment facilities and water quality enhancement projects, would be cut by $396 million, from $1.1 billion in the Fiscal Year 2007 to $687.6 million in Fiscal Year 2008.  If enacted, hundreds of thousands of people in the United States, including many AAPIs, would continue to have inadequate clean water service.

The Bush budget request would leave many low-income AAPI families vulnerable to high home energy costs.  While home heating costs have increased by 59 percent since 2001, President Bush’s budget requests have failed to keep pace — this year is no different.  While the budget requests $1.78 billion for the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), this is $420 million less than is needed to maintain LIHEAP funding at the H.J.Res.20 level, adjusted for inflation.